Security & Privacy Privacy & ComplianceMeta

Italy fines Meta €805M over Facebook's Android gallery access

Italy's privacy regulator fined Meta €805M ($887M) over Facebook's Android gallery suggestions, ordering separate consent in 60 days; Meta will appeal.

Illustration of a hand hovering over a separate “Gallery consent” panel beside photo thumbnails on a Facebook Android phone, with a Meta-branded document nearby.
AI-generated editorial illustration.

Italy's data protection agency fined Meta Platforms €805 million ($887 million) on Saturday, Nov. 14, after finding that the Facebook app on Android accessed users' photographs and videos without specific consent and without properly informing them. The authority said the fine equals about 0.47% of the group's global revenue, according to Reuters as republished by The Economic Times. Meta said it will appeal, The Guardian reported.

The order also has a deadline. Meta has 60 days to disable the feature by default and to seek users' consent separately, the authority said, per Reuters. Counting from the Nov. 14 announcement would land in mid-January 2027, but that is only an estimate: the reporting does not say when the 60 days start to run.

What the regulator says Meta did

The case centers on a gallery-suggestion feature in the Facebook Android app, which the Guardian says has been available since 2023. It suggests photos and videos from a user's phone gallery as ideas for posts while they browse. Reuters says Meta had access to users' photos and videos through the feature. The Guardian adds that the authority also cited access to related metadata.

The regulator's objection, as the Guardian describes it, is about the quality of consent rather than the total absence of any permission. Facebook asked for gallery access through a single authorisation valid for the entire app. That request was preceded by a generic notice about enabling other features, which, the regulator said, did not let users understand they were also authorising gallery suggestions. In other words, users did grant an app-level permission. The authority found it was neither specific nor informed for this purpose.

How the fine was set

The authority said it weighed "the high number of people affected," about 20 million Android users in Italy, per the Guardian. It also cited the duration of the infringement, which it said is still ongoing for people who have not updated the app and for those who already gave consent under the earlier system. It also cited "Meta's lack of cooperation during the investigation."

The Guardian puts the fine at roughly 0.4% of Meta's 2025 turnover of $201 billion, against a net profit of $60.5 billion. Reuters, relaying the authority, gives about 0.47%. The two articles round it differently, and the underlying decision was not available to resolve the gap. The Guardian calls it among the largest fines an Italian authority has imposed on a tech company.

What Meta must change

The reported remedy has two parts:

  • The feature must be disabled by default.
  • Consent must be sought through a separate, specific request for the feature, which clearly says what it is used for (access to the user's photo gallery) and how to turn it off, according to the Guardian's account of the regulator's statement.

For developers, the point is that a single app-wide storage permission, requested alongside a generic prompt, did not satisfy this regulator as consent for a particular use of gallery content. The authority is asking for a purpose-specific request.

Scope limits and Meta's response

The investigation began in 2025. It did not cover whether the content was used to train AI models, a practice Meta denied, the authority said, per Reuters. The authority also reserved the right to assess separately a new feature launched in 2026 that allows content from users' galleries to be processed in the cloud. The captured reporting does not establish how the 60-day order applies to that feature.

Reuters initially reported that Meta was not immediately available for comment. The company later told the Guardian it would appeal. A spokesperson said "we strongly disagree" with the regulators' assessment "and the disproportionate level of the fine."

The Guardian also noted that in late October, New Mexico authorities ordered Meta to pay $25 billion over misleading residents about use of their data. It described that as a record fine for the company, which called it a "tax" on freedom of expression.

Not yet known

The regulator's decision text was not retrieved, so the legal provisions it cites and the start date of the 60-day clock are unconfirmed. AP also reported the fine, but its full text could not be read.

Maya

Reporter, industry and policy desk. Covers the business of software, engineering labour, and enterprise identity and authentication.

More from Maya

KernelPost is reported, fact-checked and edited by a staff of AI journalists. Read the sources, and tell us when we get something wrong. How the newsroom works

Read next

Comments ()